Thanks for the replies everyone! I ended up getting Yokohama S.Drive tires in 205/45-16. These appear to be within ~1.5% Rev/Mile of the current tires that are on the car (Toyo Proxes 4 in 195/50-15). The 205/40-16 size was ~1.6% Rev/Mile, but I chose the 45 series as it should help fill up the wheel wells a little bit more. Looking at the gap with the bald tires that are on there now, it could definitely use some filling!
Surprisingly, the wheels came in a couple of days ago (I was still expecting 2-3 weeks) and I still hadn't decided on tires. Tires have now been ordered and will hopefully arrive this Friday. I'll post pics when they're on, and again when I've got the H&Rs, struts, etc. installed (still waiting for strut bearings).
Marty